Ice Cream Menu
Custom Blended Ice Cream
1. Choose Your Size (Dish or Cone)
2. Choose Your Base Flavor (Vanilla or Chocolate)
3. Choose Your Mix In (Add 1, 2, or 3)
Custom Mix-Ins
Almond, Apple, Banana, Birthday Cake, Blackberry, Black Cherry, Blueberry, Brownie, Butterfinger, Butter Pecan, Butterscotch, Cappuccino, Caramel, Cheesecake, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Malt, Cinnamon, Coconut, Cookies & Cream, Cookie Dough, Cream de Menthe, Graham Cracker, Heath Bar, Kit Kat, Lemon Drop, M&M, Maple Walnut, Maraschino Cherry, Marshmallow, Mandarin Orange, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cup, Peanut M&M, Peach, Peppermint, Pistachio, Reeses's Pieces, Raspberry, Root Beer, Shortbread, Snickers, Strawberry & Walnut
Junior
$3.95
​
Small
$5.75
​
Medium
$6.95
​
Large
$8.50
​
Custom Favorites
Apple Pie
Vanilla ice cream with apples, cinnamon & graham cracker
Junior
$3.95
​
Small
$5.75
​
Medium
$6.95
​
Large
$8.50
​
Berry Bash Pie
Vanilla ice cream with raspberry, blueberry, blackberry & shortbread.
$0
Black Forest Cake
Chocolate ice cream with black cherries & brownie.
$0
Blueberry Cheesecake
Vanilla ice cream with blueberries & cheesecake.
$0
Cookie Monster
Vanilla ice cream with cookies and cream & cookie dough.
$0
Fluffer Nutter
Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter, Butterfinger & marshmallow.
$0
I Want S'more
Chocolate ice cream with graham cracker, marshmallow & chocolate chips.
$0
Limon-cello
Vanilla ice cream with lemon drop, cheesecake & shortbread.
$0
Peach Cobbler
Vanilla ice cream with peaches, shortbread & cinnamon.
$0
Raspberry Truffle
Chocolate ice cream with raspberries & brownie.
$0
Rocky Road
Chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips, walnut & marshmallows.
$0
Salted Caramel Cookie
Vanilla ice cream with caramel, shortbread & sea salt.
$0
Shamrocker
Chocolate ice cream with Oreo's & Cream de Menthe.
$0
Spumoni
Vanilla ice cream with Pistachio & Maraschino cherries.
$0
Strawberry Shortcake
Vanilla ice cream with strawberries & shortbread.
$0
Teddy Bear
Vanilla ice cream with graham cracker, shortbread & cinnamon.
$0
Tiramisu
Vanilla ice cream with cappuccino, cheesecake & cookies and cream.
$0
Tortoise Shell
Vanilla ice cream with Snickers, butterscotch & cheesecake.
$0
Milkshakes
Choose your ice cream base and add any flavors/mix in's
Junior (12 oz)
$5.25
Small (16 oz)
$6.50
Medium (20oz)
$7.50
Large (24 oz)
$8.50
Soft Ice Cream
Vanilla, chocolate or twist
Junior
$3.50
Small
$4.25
Medium
$5.25
Large
$6.25
Alcohol Infused Ice Cream
Must be over 21 to purchase - we have constant rotating flavors!
Sundae's
Banana Split
$8.95
Brownie Sundae
$8.95
Grand Slam Sundae
$17.95
Address
Contact
hours
4833 State Highway 28
Cooperstown, NY 13326
OPENING DATE: May 23, 2025
Open May - August
Daily Hours:
11:30am – 10:00pm